The government has no convincing case for spending £50bn building the HS2 rail link between London and the North, a report by the House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee says.
The government’s main arguments in favour of HS2 – increasing railway capacity and rebalancing the economy – were still to be proven, peers said.
There are less-expensive options than HS2, they said on Wednesday.
A government spokesman said HS2 would deliver big benefits.
Lord Hollick, chairman of the Lords’ committee, said overcrowding on the West Coast Main Line was largely a problem on commuter trains and on long-distance services on Friday nights and some weekends.
“The Government have not carried out a proper assessment of whether alternative ways of increasing capacity are more cost-effective than HS2,” he said.
“In terms of rebalancing, London is likely to be the main beneficiary from HS2. Investment in improving rail links in the North of England might deliver much greater economic benefit at a fraction of the cost.”
Committee member and Labour peer Lord McFall told Wake Up to Money on BBC Radio 5 live that the committee was not against HS2 in principle, but that the government needed a firmer transport strategy if it wanted to achieve its aim of rebalancing the economy.
“We’re against the government initiating public projects at £50bn without adequate assessment against their objectives,” he said.
“Can you imagine going forward with a project of this magnitude without a national transport strategy?” Lord McFall added.
“If we’re going to rebalance the economy, then we must have a fundamental appraisal of the impact in the North, and that hasn’t taken place to date,”
‘Satisfactory answers’
Lord Hollick called on the Department for Transport to provide detailed answers to the questions set out by the committee.
“Parliament should not approve the enabling legislation that will allow HS2 work to begin until we have satisfactory answers to these key questions,” he said.
The peer sets out arguments against the investment in a YouTube video.
A Department for Transport spokesman said the case for HS2 was “crystal clear” and claimed it would have a “transformational effect”.
“It is a vital part of the government’s long-term economic plan, strongly supported by Northern and Midland cities, alongside our plans for better east-west rail links confirmed in the Northern Transport Strategy last week.
“Demand for long distance rail travel has doubled in the past 15 years… it is crucial we press ahead with delivering HS2 on time and budget and we remain on track to start construction in 2017,” the spokesman said.
‘No blank cheque’
Shadow transport secretary Michael Dugher said that Labour supported HS2. However, he added: “It’s vital that ministers win public confidence for this important investment and ensure that the economic benefits are felt as widely as possible. We have said there will be no blank cheque for the project under Labour.”
Rhian Kelly, CBI director for business environment, said a modern railway was needed to deal with lack of capacity on the West Coast Mainline.
“HS2 will better connect eight of our 10 biggest cities, boosting local economies along and beyond the route together with complementary road and rail investment. It’s vital we avoid any further delays to the project,” she said.
HS2 route
The proposed route for HS2 has attracted protests from some residents
The Lords report echoed a similar report published by the Commons Public Accounts Committee in January.
The MPs said that ministers lacked a “clear strategic plan for the rail network” and were “sceptical” about whether HS2 would deliver value for money.
The £50bn price tag included a “generous contingency” that could be used to mask cost increases, they added.
The first phase of HS2 will be between London and Birmingham opening in 2026, followed by a V-shaped section to Manchester and Yorkshire.
It promises to reduce journey times between Birmingham and London from 81 minutes to 49 minutes, and slash the trip to Manchester by an hour to just 68 minutes.
Search
-
Latest Updates
- 2021 – 022 Things to come – or may be here now. 22 January, 2021
- 2021 – 022 Woke companies 21 January, 2021
- 2020 – 21 An improved solution to the accommodating of illegal migrants 31 December, 2020
- 2020 – 020 Why you shouldn’t believe the COVID vaccine is effective 22 December, 2020
- 2020 – 019 How the enemies of democracy have been at work 17 December, 2020
- 2021 – 018 Videos of the Police we have now 15 December, 2020
- 2020 – 017 FALSE AND DECEPTIVE UN AND WEF NARRATIVES – ALL PART OF THE ONE WORLD GOVERNMENT AGENDA OF CONTROL 18 November, 2020
- 2020 – 016 US Voter fraud so far 13 November, 2020
- 2020 – 015 The people v the Judges Comment on High Court Judgment of 3 November 2016 4 November, 2020
- 20214 MAGGY OLIVER’S FULL 58 PAGE STATEMENT SUPPLIED TO THE IICSA ORGANISED NETWORKS STRAND OF THE NATIONAL ABUSE ENQUIRY IN SEPTEMBER 2020. 6 October, 2020
- 2020 – 013 NEW REPORT ON REPLACEMENT MIGRATION ISSUED BY UN POPULATION DIVISION 5 October, 2020
- 2020 – 012 Why defund the World Health Organisation? 13 September, 2020
- 2020 – 011 The Appointment of Judges 9 September, 2020
- 2020 – 008 Books to read during house arrest 4 April, 2020
- 2020 – 007 The European Court of Human Rights lies in ruins after judges’ links to Soros revealed 1 March, 2020
- 2020 – 006 Not the Fake News Feb 2020 no 7 18 February, 2020
- 2020 – 005 Understand why Supertrawlers are fishing UK waters 12 February, 2020
- 2020 – 004 Why does the MSM refer to Muslim rapists as Asian? 9 February, 2020
- 2020 – 004 Fishing, Factortame and British sovereignty. 6 February, 2020
- 2022 – 003 Understanding the WTO/EU situation 23 January, 2020
- 2020 – 002 How the leader of the 1922 committee supported May against the Tory Party 19 January, 2020
- 2020 – 001 Grooming gang statistics 17 January, 2020
- 2019 – 044 The 5 Global States of Coudenhove. 13 December, 2019
- 2020 – 006 NOT THE FAKE NEWS Feb 2020 11 December, 2019
- 2019 – 042 The meeting between May and Merkel where they agreed on treason against the UK 10 December, 2019
- (no title) 23 November, 2019
- 2019 – 40 Orwell and why the British Elite so despise Britain 19 November, 2019
- 2019 – 039 Who Are the “Experts” on Climate Change? 23 October, 2019
- (no title) 19 October, 2019
- 2019 – 036 Voting for Mayor of London 15 October, 2019
- 2019 – 035 THE KILMUIR LETTER- A damning Critique over UK’s ‘ILLEGAL’ entry into the EEC! 13 October, 2019
- 2019 – 034 Corbyn’s CV 10 October, 2019
- 2019 – 033 The “climate doom” timeline 29 September, 2019
- 2019 – 032 Proposal for UK citizenship post Brexit 27 September, 2019
- 2019 – 031 France and Spain in revolt 23 September, 2019
- 2019 – 30 Prorogation of Parliament. 14 September, 2019
- 2019 – 029 Operation Yellowhammer 13 September, 2019
- 2019 – 028 The strategy behind the exit deal’s defense sellout of the UK army 12 September, 2019
- (no title) 29 August, 2019
- 2019- 026 UK fracking and earthquakes 27 August, 2019
- (no title) 23 August, 2019
- 2019 – 024 Common Purpose 8 June, 2019
- 2019 – 023 – Reporting the fraudulent practices behind global warming science 3 June, 2019
- 2019 – 022 I’m a police officer in London. Here’s why we’ve lost control of the streets 4 May, 2019
- 2019 – 022 John Redwood MP’s in EXPLOSIVE letter 4 May, 2019
- 2019 – 21 Rodney Atkinson’s assessment of May’s Withdrawal Treaty 25 April, 2019
- 2019 – 020 Brexit Briefing – a synopsis of the EU and New World Order 24 April, 2019
- (no title) 23 April, 2019
- 2019 – 015 EXPLOSIVE SLOG SPECIAL: HOW MAY WAS INSTALLED, HOW SHE HID DEFENSE TIES TO THE EU, HOW THE MEDIA LIED ABOUT THE OCTOBER BREXTENSION 19 April, 2019
- 2019 – 014 EU funding of the BBC 3 April, 2019
- 2019 – 013 operationcomeuppance 14 March, 2019
- 2019 – 012 If UK stays in the EU these are the consequences. 14 March, 2019
- 2019 -011 A more detailed account of May’s betrayal of Brexit with Merkel 8 March, 2019
- 2019 – 009 May is far, far more underhand and deceitful than we ever thought possible. 6 March, 2019
- 2019 – 008 how to understand EU costing 1 March, 2019
- 2019 – 007 Common Purpose are at the Center of Government, the Civil Service and the Conservative Party. 28 February, 2019
- 2019 – 006 Mockingbird update 10 February, 2019
- 2019 – 005 Secret trilogue meetings in the EU 9 February, 2019
- 2019 – 004 THE HISTORY AND AIMS OF THE EU, UN and New World Order 9 February, 2019
- 2019 – 003 Neofunctionalism 9 February, 2019
- 2019 – 002 There is a World Wide struggle going on how to control the World. 4 February, 2019
- 2019 – 001 May’s not so squeaky clean past 4 February, 2019
- 2019 – 044 How the UN controls migration into Western Culture countries 27 January, 2019
- 2019 – 013 What is Operation Comeuppance 27 January, 2019
- 2018 – 042 Who is the Father of the EU? Not Jean Monnet. 3 December, 2018
- 2018 – 041 The Rules of Political Correctness 29 November, 2018
- 2018 – 040 Deep State – who are they? 28 November, 2018
- 2018 – 039 Rodney Atkinson assesses May’s surrender document 21 November, 2018
- 2018 – 038 May’s 13 Brexit mistakes 9 November, 2018
- 2018 – 037 UK citizenship post Brexit 27 October, 2018
- 2018 – 036 14 October, 2018
- 2018 – 035 Essential Books to read to Understand to Threat of the EU and the New World Order 18 September, 2018
- 2018 – 034 Andrew Marr on forced mixed marriages. 17 September, 2018
- 2018 – 033 EU Article 13 A move to control the Internet 12 September, 2018
- 2018 – 032 Common Agricultural policy 5 September, 2018
- 2018 – 031 Why is the UK Prison Service in such Chaos? 26 August, 2018
- 2018 – 030 THE HISTORY AND AIMS OF THE EU and New World Order. 9 August, 2018
- 2018 – 029 How the early UK Deep state connived secretly to get UK into the EU 7 August, 2018
- 2018 – 028 Deep State who are they? 25 July, 2018
- 2018 – 027 Difference between the population and the Establishment over Brexit 14 July, 2018
- 2018 – 0026 EU paid 160 million euro to pro Remain groups. 5 July, 2018
- 2018 – 025 How the NUJ muzzled journalists on naming Ethnic minority felons. 16 June, 2018
- 2018 – 024 blank 27 May, 2018
- 2018 – 023 United Nations Migration Chief Claims Mass Migration in ‘National Interest’ 22 May, 2018
- 2018 – 022 The Libertas saga and how the Electoral Commission tried to bankrupt UKIP. 20 May, 2018
- 2018 – 021 Arc Manche A secret EU a plan to carve up UK. 15 May, 2018
- 2018 – 020 Speech to the DIEXODUS DEMONSTRATION by Edward Spalton 11 May, 2018
- 2018 – 019 Letter to May on Islam. 10 May, 2018
- 2018 – 018 How the Educational Authorities produced Generation Snowflake 8 May, 2018
- 2018 – 017 The EU’s intention to prevent free speech on the internet 30 April, 2018
- 2018 – 016 Who do you belong to? 27 April, 2018
- 2018 – 015 response to petition to keep UK military out of EU control 11 April, 2018
- 2018 – 014 Slavery in the USA 9 April, 2018
- 2018 – 013 19 March, 2018
- 2018 – 011 Fallen Soldier has his say 13 March, 2018
- 2018 – 012 Social Media bypasses Main Stream Media 13 March, 2018
- 2018 – 009 If Britain is to Brexit properly, it must get out of the EU’s Defence Union 4 March, 2018
- 2018 – 008 PLAN FOR A UNITED STATES OF EUROPE WHICH IS TO BE CONTROLLED BY A NEW WORLD ORDER. 22 February, 2018
- 2018 – 007 EU intends to control all artistic activities and copyright 3 February, 2018
- 2018 – 006 EU intends to control all journalists with an EU Press Card 2 February, 2018
- 2018 – 005 EU intend all copyright to become the property of the EU on expiry 2 February, 2018
- 2018 – 004 Freedom of the press and the Parole Board 28 January, 2018
- 2018 – 003 THE HISTORY of the EU 28 January, 2018
- 2018 – 002 More on Common Purpose 1 January, 2018
- 2018 – 001 How the Gov lied to the British people to join the EU 31 December, 2017
- 2017 -60 How schools have improved since 1950 14 December, 2017
- (no title) 14 December, 2017
- 2019 – 006 Operation Mockingbird update 1 December, 2017
- 2018 – 058 THE HISTORY AND AIMS OF THE EU, UN and New World Order 12 November, 2017
- 2017 – 057 The National Society for the prevention of Cruelty to Vegetables 1 November, 2017
- 2017 – 055 The Spanish experience with the EU 29 October, 2017
- 2017 – 054 The very serious threat of the EU army having control in UK post Brexit 26 October, 2017
- 2017 – 053 Was Randolf Churchill hoodwinked by Bromley Council? 25 October, 2017
- 2017 – 052 EU press card to control all journalists 16 October, 2017
- 2017 – 051 Hammond blocking Brexit 15 October, 2017
- 2017 – 050 How the EU is leading the UK into a negotiating quick sand 13 October, 2017
- 2017 – 049 Driving Awareness course – poor and dangerous advice 12 October, 2017
- 2017 – 048 The sinister EU Defense Union. 11 October, 2017
- 2017 – 047 Brave New Europe? 9 October, 2017
- 2017 – 046 EU intentions for Acquiring all Copyright on the death of the owner. 8 October, 2017
- 2017 – 045 Desecration of Biggin Hill Memorial Chapel 26 September, 2017
- 2017 – 044 A German view of Islam 19 September, 2017
- 2017 – 043 Political Correctness is about control not etiquette 19 September, 2017
- 2017 – 042 Christopher Booker The monstous folly of the Green Blob. 18 September, 2017
- 2017 – 040 The 1971 FCO 30/1048: Heath knew it was treason 18 September, 2017
- 2017 – 039 The folly of electric cars 17 September, 2017
- 2017 – 038 Is the EU Democratic? 14 September, 2017
- 2017 – 037 UK Law vs EU Law 2 September, 2017
- 2017 – 036 Free Speech 27 August, 2017
- 2017 – 035 Brave New Europe? Amazon reviews 27 August, 2017
- 2017 – 034 More on Cultural Marxism and the Frankfurt School 10 August, 2017
- 2017 – 033 Brave New Europe Amazon reviews 8 August, 2017
- 2017 – 032 Europa, Eurabia and the Last man 31 July, 2017
- 2017 – 031 The Perfect Pension Party 27 July, 2017
- 2017 – 030 More Global Warming Fraud 26 July, 2017
- 2017 – 028 Amazon 26 July, 2017
- 2017 – 027 An excellent expose of Common Purpose 24 July, 2017
- 2017 – 026 Who was responsible for Grenfell Tower Tradegy. 2 July, 2017
- 017 – 025 3 US presidents and illegal migrants 29 June, 2017
- 2017 – 024 GERMAN-ISLAM CONNECTION GOES BACK TO WW1 29 June, 2017
- 2017 – 023 Lord Walsingham’s Witness to History on the origins of the EU 29 June, 2017
- 2017 – 022 Global Warming is Fake Science 18 June, 2017
- 2017 – 021 Did Tory Remainers sabotage May’s election? 10 June, 2017
- 2017 – 020 Hidden costs of the EU 8 June, 2017
- 2017 – 019 The European Union’s Evil Pedigree – Berlin 1942 by Edward Spalton 14 May, 2017
- 2017 – 018 New book a must read Brave New Europe 11 May, 2017
- 2017 – 017 How Germany and France conspired against Britain when the EU started 5 May, 2017
- 2017 – 016 EU to confiscate all copyright and control all artistic activities. 2 May, 2017
- 2017 – 015 BRITISH POLITICS 2017. LIES, MORE LIES, DECEITS AND RIPOFFS. 30 April, 2017
- 2017 – 014 Bilderberg attendees 25 April, 2017
Hurrah! At last I got a blolg from where I be capable of in fact take helpful information regarding my
study and knowledge.
My webpage Talent Recruitment
Thank you – please forward theeuroprobe.org on to all your contacts.